Details
-
Improvement
-
Status: Open
-
Critical
-
Resolution: Unresolved
-
0.28.1
-
None
-
None
-
DCOS 1.7 Cloud Formation scripts
Description
We have observed a situation where Mesos will kill tasks belonging to a framework where that framework times out with the Mesos master for some reason, perhaps even because of a network partition.
While we can provide a long timeout so that Mesos will not kill a framework's tasks for practical purposes, I'm wondering if there's an improvement where a framework shouldn't be permitted to re-register for a given id (as now), but Mesos doesn't also kill tasks? What I'm thinking is that Mesos could be "told" by an operator that this condition should be cleared.
IMHO frameworks should be the only entity requesting that tasks be killed unless manually overridden by an operator.
I'm flagging this as a critical improvement because a) the focus should be on keeping tasks running in a system, and it isn't; and b) Mesos is working as designed.
In summary I feel that Mesos is taking on a responsibility in killing tasks where it shouldn't be.
Attachments
Issue Links
- is related to
-
MESOS-4659 Avoid leaving orphan task after framework failure + master failover
- Accepted